The Maccabean period seems to furnish adequate background for the national petitions, though the experiences of the Roman war and the subsequent disasters may have heightened the coloring in many details. ; Ps. xiii.). At public worship, when the precentor, or, as he is known in Hebrew, the Shelia ibbur (messenger or deputy of the congregation) , repeats the prayer aloud, the preceding benediction (No. Paying close . Even so do Thou keep us alive and preserve us, and gather together our exiles to Thy holy courts to keep thy statutes and to do Thy will and to serve Thee with a fully devoted heart, for which we render thanks unto Thee. Abudarham quotes, "and Thy name be exalted constantly and forever and aye"; while Saadia's version reads: "on account of all, be Thou blessed and exalted; for Thou art the Only One in the universe, and there is none besides Thee." It is called the Amidah because when at all possible, . 153. viii. Blessed be Thou, O Eternal, who answerest in time of trouble." 21 et seq. 6 (on the strength of which was printed the emendation "Ha-Mufadot" for the "Ha-Peudot"); Jer. Teh.) ", Slight verbal modifications are found also in the Sephardic "Hoda'ah"; e.g., "and they [the living] shall praise and bless Thy great name in truth forever; for good [is] the God, our help and our aid, Selah, the God, the Good." (the benediction for the year) the words "dew and rain" are inserted during the term from the sixtieth day after the autumnal equinox to Passover. des Volkes Israel, iii. 18a); or, as R. Johanan has it: "Whoever exaggerates the laudations of the Holy Onepraised be He!will be uprooted from the world" (ib.). For a God that heareth prayers and supplications art Thou. 17a), during the Middle Ages was added "do on account of Thy name," etc. In the final part of the benediction appears all introductory petition on the three joyous festivals: "Let us receive, O Lord our God, the blessings of Thy appointed times for life and peace, for gladness and joy, wherewith Thou in Thy favor hast promised to bless us." iii. 5; Ezek. . v. 2; Ta'an. 18, cix. Gradually both the hours for the "Tefillah" and the formulas thereof acquiredgreater regularity, though much uncertainty as to content, sequence, and phraseology continued to prevail. ii. iii. Although it is true that virtually no interruptions are permitted between ga'al Yisrael and the beginning of Shemoneh Esrei, these three steps are deemed to be a component of the prayer, and as such Blessed be Thou, O Lord, who blessest Thy [His] people Israel with peace.". (3) In many of alir's compositionsstill used in the Italian ritualfor Purim, Hosha'na Rabbah, the Seventeenth of Tammuz, and the Tenth of ebet, in which he follows the sequence of the "Tefillah," this No. Jol, "Blicke in die Religionsgeschichte," i. ], and heal our sick [= viii. xxxi. Again, "our sicknesses" takes the place of "our sores or wounds." v.; Ber. R. Gamaliel II. And remove from us bodily pain; and fatten us with the fertility of Thy land; and our dispersed ones from the four corners of the earth do Thou gather together; and they that go astray against the knowledge of Thee shall be judged; and upon the evil-doers do Thou lift up Thy hand: but may the righteous rejoice in the building of Thy city, and in the refounding of Thy Temple, and in the sprouting up of a horn unto David Thy servant, and in the preparing of a light for Jesse's son, Thy Messiah. 11 is the proof that this system of praying three times a day was recognized in the Maccabean era. at Jabneh. 8; Ps. xxviii. v. was spoken over Reuben and Bilhah (or when Manasseh the king repented; ib. Once a week for nineteen weeks, we will review the contents of the 19 blessings of "Shemoneh Esrei." xiv. ", "[Thou wilt] dwell in the midst of Jerusalem, Thy city, as Thou hast spoken [promised], and the throne of David Thy servant speedily in its midst [Thou wilt] establish, and build it an everlasting building soon in our days. In dangerous places a very brief formula was, according to R. Joshua, substituted: "Help, O Eternal, Thy people, the remnant of Israel. ii. The Amidah is also called Shemoneh Esrei, which means "eighteen" (8+10), since originally there were eighteen blessings of the Amidah divided into three general types: Praise - The first three blessings: Avot, Gevurot, and Kedushat HaShem . Rabbi Chaim Soloveitchik adds an additional requirement for the first paragraph of the Shemoneh Esrei: One must understand its words. vi. That the Mishnah fails to record the text or to give other definite and coherent directions concerning the prayer except sporadically, indicates that when the Mishnah was finally compiled the benedictions were so well known that it was unnecessary to prescribe their text andcontent (Maimonides on Men. . xviii. Shemona Esrei definition and meaning - Collins Dictionary If this construction of Ben Sira's prayer is admissible, many of the benedictions must be assigned to the Maccabean era, though most scholars have regardedthem as posterior to the destruction of the Temple. 8a, above; Lev. ii., after the words "Thou resurrectest the dead and art great to save" is inserted the words: "Thou causest the wind to blow and the rain to descend." In this most difficult period after . Ber. This prayer is the cornerstone of every Jewish service. x. is the benediction in regard to the "ibbu Galuyot," the gathering of the Jews of the Diaspora (Meg. A Habdalah is inserted on Saturday night in the "Sanctification of the Day" when a festivaland this can never happen with the Day of Atonementfalls on a Sunday. Blessed be Thou, O Lord, Thy name is good, and to Thee it is meet to give thanks.". Shabbos Shacharis Shemoneh Esrei: Why V'shamru? As for those that think evil of [against] me speedily thwart their counsel and destroy their plots. 81 et seq. xii. . Ber. 28a) and R. Simeon ben Yoai (Ab. From this it appears that No. 8b), a principle said to have been carried into practise by R. Eleazar and R. Abbahu (ib.). In praying for the new month the Portuguese ritual adds: "May this month be the last of all our troubles, a beginning of our redemption." xvi. 1; Tamid vii. lxviii. 17b): "Restore our judges as of yore, and our counselors as in the beginning, and remove from us grief and sighing. A century later the Sadducees furnished the type, hence it came to be designated as the "Birkat ha-adduim" (but "adduim" may in this connection be merely a euphemism for "Minim"; Yer. Trending on HowToPronounce Lahmi [en] Renee [en] Jvke [en] . i. ix. to Israel's salvation at the Red Sea; No. is a prayer in behalf of the "addiim" = "pious" (Meg. 7. Ber. 30 et seq.). ], xviii., and xix.). ); they involved the Jews in difficulties with the Roman government (Tosef., ul. "The holy ones," ib. Which of the two views is the more plausible it is difficult to decide. R. Jose held that one should include something new in one's prayer every day (Yer. 'May the Eternal let His countenance shine upon thee and be gracious unto thee. cxxxii. Do not turn to our wickedness, and do not hide, O our King, from our supplication. Shemoneh Esrei in the lexicon of Judaism, tefillah-prayer refers to the Shemoneh Esrei (or Amidah). xi. ); when Isaac was saved by the substitution of the ram they chanted ". The "Ge'ullah," redemption, should be the seventh benediction (Meg. vi. p. 55) for the congregation at Cairo, though not in his "Yad"(see "Yad," Tefillin, ix. the Sephardic ritual introduces before "the elders" the phrase "and on the remnant of Thy people, the house of Israel," while in some editions these words are entirely omitted, and before the conclusion this sentence is inserted: "on Thy great loving-kindness in truth do we rely for support. 9. iii. Fill our hands with Thy blessings and the richness of the gifts of Thy hands. "Healest the sick," Ex. the resurrection is replaced by "sustaining in life the whole" and by "redeeming the soul of His servants from death." xvii. As the Syrians were aided by the apostates, the "zedim," these were also embraced in the imprecatory appeal. as No. shemoneh esrei - Why are you allowed to say the elokay nitzor in the The last part is modified on New Moon. 10; Gen. xv. des Achtzehngebets, in Monatsschrift, 1902. ii. v. ("Lead us back, our Father," etc.) 45a, in the uncensored editions; the censored have "Mumar"). i. As soon as the dispersed (No. You can use them to display text, links, images, HTML, or a combination of these. 154 (comp. The palpable emphasis of No. 17b) because redemption will take place on the seventh day, or rather, as stated by the "Cuzari" and the "ur," because the result of forgiveness is redemption. communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Do [this] for Thy name's sake, do this for Thy right hand's sake, do this for the sake of Thy holiness, do this for the sake of Thy Torah. And for these very reasons, many people struggle to experience the Shemoneh Esrei as something beyond a ritual formality. In No. No. The conclusion is either "who breakest the enemies" (Midr. If it is Shabbat and Rosh Chodesh, they . viii. For Thou art a God ransoming and helping and answering and showing mercy in all time of trouble and distress. Lift up in glory hand and right arm. In Babylon this became the rule, but in Palestine the "Tefillah" was read aloud by the congregation (Mller, "illufim," No. Buber, p. 21; SeMaG, command No. '", Then followed a final phrase praying for the rebuilding of the Temple so that Israel might sacrifice again, to the sweet gratification of God as of yore. No. also Isa. Ta'an. is styled "Birkat ha-Ge'ullah," the benediction ending with "Go'el" = "Redeemer" (Meg. Getting back to Shemoneh Esrei, the Talmud in Megillah 17b tells us that the reason the bracha of kibbutz galuyos comes after birkas hashanim - which is about abundant produce - is because the land of Israel will bloom in anticipation of the Jews' return as per Ezekiel 36:8, "You mountains of Israel will shoot forth your branches and . p. xvii. Visit Stack Exchange Tour Start here for quick overview the site Help Center Detailed answers. This was done so that people who did not know how . be pleased with our rest; sanctify us by Thy commandments, give us a share in Thy law, satiate us of Thy bounty, and gladden us in Thy salvation; and cleanse our hearts to serve Thee in truth: let us inherit, O Lord our God, in love and favor, Thy holy Sabbath, and may Israel, who hallows [loves] Thy name, rest thereon. Three times a day, Jews recite the Shemoneh Esrei, requesting that the Creator grant them knowledge and justice, forgiveness and healing, redemption and peace. Another emendation was "We-la-posh'im" (idem, "Ritus," p. 89), which readily gave way to the colorless "We-la-malshinim" (in the German ritual among others). Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates. vi. "Meshummad" designates a Jew who apostatizes (Ramban on Ex. On. In fall and winter, in No. The anti-Sadducean protest in this benediction is evident. 26b; Gen. R. iii. (1896) 142 et seq. n Judaism the central prayer in each of the daily services, recited silently and standing. ix. According to this, seventeen was the number of benedictions without the "Birkat ha-adduim." viii. p. 149). 11a; Targ. ", Verse 6. Al Hanissim on Chanukah - Halachipedia . li. 3). for deliverance, happiness, life, and peace; remember us thereon, O Lord our God, for happiness, visit us for blessings, save us unto life, and with words of help and mercy spare and favor us, show us mercy! "Fill Zion with Thy splendor and with Thy glory Thy Temple. ; R. Samuel bar Naman, in Yer. iv. Soah 22a, and in the commentary of R. Hananeel on Yoma l.c., the reading is: ), while in the "Hoda'ah" the ending is almost as now, = "Thou, the one to whom it is good to give thanks." No. are not specific in content. ; Yer. xii.) to the Israelites' conquest of the land after which they had peace. iv.). Another mnemonic reference, based upon the number of times the names of the three Patriarchs occur together in the Pentateuch (Gen. R. Its words and themes are a kind of mantra embedded in the minds and memory of all who recite it. 22 or Ps. As the title suggests, this is an anthology of various thanksgiving prayers composed by the Rabbis (Soah 9a). 89 et seq.). l.c.) Next to the Shema, the Amidahis the most widely recitedHebrew in the world. vi. The prayer was in fact designated even in later days as , a petition to humiliate the arrogant ("zedim"; Yer. Blessed be Thou, O Eternal, maker of peace.". 5a; Sanh. ); (5) the eighteen names of Yhwh in Miriam's song by the sea (Ex. The abstracts, however, throw light on what may have been the number of the benedictions before Gamaliel fixed it at eighteen by addition of the petition for the punishment of traitors ("wela-malshinim") The Babylonian Talmud has preserved one version; Yerushalmi, another (or two: a longer and a briefer form, of which the fragments have been combined; see J. Derenbourg in "R. E. ", So, also, Saadia: "and Thou wilt be pleased with us as of yore." iv. after the words "from everlasting we have hoped in Thee." The "Hoda'ah" (No. Our Creator, the Creator of all in the beginning: [we offer] benedictions and thanksgivings unto Thy name, the great and holy One, because Thou hast kept us alive and preserved us. And for all these things may Thy name be blessed and exalted always and forevermore. 17b; Yer. 1b, quoted by Elbogen, "Gesch. or "humiliates the arrogant" (Amram); in the former phrase Saadia and Maimonides replace the noun "enemies" by "evil-doers.". ], bless our years with dews of blessing [ix. In work-day services the Shemoneh 'Esreh continues with Group 2 ("Baashot"), supplications referring to the needs of Israel (Sifre, Wezot ha-Berakah, ed. The Shemona Esrei: Its Structure and Meaning - webyeshiva.org In support of this is the notation of what now is No. (ed. Shemoneh Esrei | The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com Rabbi Akiva says, "If he knows it fluently, he should say . xv. i., ii., iii. Kedushat Hashem. vouchsafing knowledge" (No. Ich wei nicht, ob es damit . 17 (comp. Firstly, the mishna relates to what is known as an "ABRIDGED Shemoneh Esrei". . v. 16], 'The Lord God is exalted in judgment, and the Holy God is sanctified in righteousness.' could not have been used before the destruction of the Temple. "Kol Bo" gives the number of the words contained therein as thirty-two, which agrees with none of the extant recensions. 28b). xi. No. 28b). the Vitry, Mazor has "a God good and forgiving art Thou" instead of "pardoning and forgiving," thus conforming with the readings of Amram, Maimonides, and the Roman Mazor. i. In the Roman Mazor the phraseology is: "From generation to generation we shall proclaim God King, for He alone is exalted and holy; and Thy praise, O our God, shall not depart from our mouth forever and aye, for a God great and holy art Thou. SHEMONEH 'ESREH - JewishEncyclopedia.com 26. ii., after "salvation to sprout forth," "Who is like Thee, Father of mercies, who rememberest His [Thy] creatures unto life in mercy? 17; see Ber. . It is also known as Shemoneh Esrei, meaning eighteen, because it originally consisted of eighteen blessings, and as tefilah (prayer) because in . iii. 22; Ta'an. For instance, the "ur" gives the verse Isa. Understanding the Shemoneh Esrei. The "Roea," however, reports only seventeen words, as in the German version. xv. Shemoneh Esrei-Jewish Used Books R. anina took occasion to reprove very severely a reader who added attribute to attribute while addressing the Deity. on the resurrection (hence one of its names, "Teiyyat ha-Metim"; Ber. is the "Birkat ha-olim" ('Ab. Understanding the Shemoneh Esrei; The Philosophy of Shemitta; Theological Issues in Sefer BeReishit; Jewish Political Theory - Hilkhot Melakhim; Meaning in Mitzvot; Philosophy of Halakha; Understanding the Practice and Meaning of Halakha; A River Goes Out of Eden It says that he received the Luchos, on which were written the Mitzvah of Shabbos, "and so too is it . 107a), why God is called the God of Abraham but not the God of David, suggests the elimination of "Elohe Dawid" from benediction No. lxxxix. 17b); and when this hastaken place all treason (No. Ist dies auerdem nur in Nusach Chabad oder lassen andere Nusach Sefard-Versionen diese Wrter weg? iv. Thou art surely believed to resurrect the dead. ; "Monatsschrift," 1902, p. 353). The first and more popular tradition: Most people take a total of three steps before Shemoneh Esrei by moving their left foot to the heel of the right foot [first step] and then move the right foot to the heel of the left foot [second step] and then move the left foot to be symmetric with the right foot [third step]. ii. On Sabbaths and holy days there is only one middle benediction, an enlarged "Sanctification of the Day." It goes without saying that parts of the present text of No. i., while 1b is the key-note of the prayer for Rosh ha-Shanah. ; comp. None of them may be assigned to a date before the Maccabean era, while for many a later one is suggested by the content. Ta'an. R. Eliezer, the son of R. Zadok, virtually repeated the preceding, with merely the substitution of a synonym for "cry." For example, if one only knows a portion of the Brachot it is better not to say anything. ; Gutmann, in "Monatsschrift," 1898, p. 344). "Understanding," Isa. May it be good in Thine eyes to bless" (and so forth as in the preceding form). iv. Blessed be Thou, O Eternal, who answerest in time of trouble.". iv. Eighteen corresponds to the eighteen times God's name is mentioned in Ps. 8). When Abraham was saved the angels recited the "Blessed be Thou . iv. J." ", Moreover, in the Sephardic ritual a number of individual petitions are admitted in various benedictions, which is not the case in the Ashkenazic. Cause Thou to rise up full healings for all our wounds: for Thou, God King, art a true and merciful physician: blessed be Thou, O Lord, who healest the sick of His people Israel.". cxlv. "Summon wrath and pour out glowing anger. Blessed be Thou, O Eternal, who hearest prayer". The first of the seven enumerated is identical with the one contained in the "Shemoneh 'Esreh" as No. The worshiper was bidden to remain at the place whither his three backward steps had brought him for the space of time which would be required for traversing a space of four ells, or, if at public prayer-service, until the precentor, in the loud repetition, intoned the "edushshah.". (1) While recited in the Temple, the original conclusion of benedictions was "Blessed be Thou, O Eternal, God of Israel from eternity to eternity" (Ber. xv. xv. According to Sephardim all the brachot of Shemonah Esrei all necessary and one may not say a portion of them without the others. 29, 57b; Pes. On New Moons and middle days, except in the Musaf, the "Ya'aleh we-yabo" (see above) is inserted in the "'Abodah" before "bring back." The Depth and Beauty of Our Daily Tefillah Da Nusach Chabad technisch gesehen eine Variation von Nusach Sefard ist, warum wird Tzur Jisroel" aus dem Text weggelassen? While the Germans quote in the prayer the language of the Pentateuch in reference to the sacrifices, the Sephardim omit it. xxv. At the center of the Jewish daily prayers are the 19 blessings that make up the silent prayer, known in Hebrew as the Amidah (lit. xix., however, is a rsum of this blessing. May it be a pleasure from before Thee, O Eternal, our God, to vouchsafe unto each sufficiency of sustenance and to each and every one enough to satisfy his wants. vi. No. He then ends the benediction as usual and reads the "Modim" as well as the introduction to the priestly blessing (see Blessing, Priestly): "Our God and God of our fathers, bless us with the blessing which, tripartite in the Torah, was written by the hands of Moses, Thy servant, and was spoken by Aaron and his sons the priests, Thy holy people, as follows [at this point the priests say aloud]: "Blessed be Thou, O Eternal our God, King of the universe, who hast sanctified us with the sacredness of Aaron and hast commanded us in love to bless Thy (His) people Israel.". vi. Blessed be Thou, O Lord, who hearest prayer" (Ber. Rabbi Simlai expounded: "A man should always . This blessing was not part of the original formulation of the Shemoneh Esrei . ix. xiv. Note that the blessings should be recited while standing, with quiet devotion and without interruption. Maimonides and Amram likewise do not use the formula beginning with the words "Shalom rab." In order to remove the discrepancies between the latter and the former assignment of editorship, the Talmud takes refuge in the explanation that the prayers had fallen into disuse, and that Gamaliel reinstituted them (Meg. . 5). The verse marked 5, indeed, seems to be a commentary on benediction No. 186-197, Berlin, 1897; Elbogen, Die Gesch. xxix. 115b; Yer. for the Sabbath the Sephardim add on Friday evening lines which the Ashkenazim include only in the additional service (see Dembitz, l.c. "my soul"] be silent, and me [my soul] be like dust to all. While praying, concentrate on the meaning of the words, and remember that you stand before the divine presence. In No. 23. Mystical prayers and practices existed in which worshippers would attempt to ascend to heaven and come into the presence of God. 2.After sunrise until a third of the day has passed. The function of blessing the people the Pharisees would not and could not arrogate unto themselves. Then why pick on V'shamru when there are plenty of other parshios that discuss Shabbos? R. Judah ha-Nasi desired to have it used on the Sabbath as well as on week-days (Yer. The exact form and order of the blessings were codified after the destruction of the Second Temple in the first century C.E. xix.). May our eyes behold Thy return to Zion in mercy, and there we shall serve Thee in awe, as in the days of old and in former years". On festivals (even when coincident with the Sabbath) this "Sanctification of the Day" is made up of several sections, the first of which is constant and reads as follows: "Thou hast chosen us from all the nations, hast loved us and wast pleased with us; Thou hast lifted us above all tongues, and hast hallowed us by Thy commandments, and hast brought us, O our King, to Thy service, and hast pronounced over us Thy great and holy name.". cxlvii. Shemona Esrei definition: the central prayer in each of the daily services, recited silently and standing | Meaning, pronunciation, translations and examples 25a; Ber. 5; Isa. shemoneh esrei - Musaf verses for Rosh Chodesh on Rosh Hashanah - Mi Yodeya to Solomon's bringing the Ark into the inner sanctuary; No. Ber. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright . O be merciful, in Thy great mercies bring back Thy Shekinah to Zion and rearrange the sacrificial service for Jerusalem, and do Thou in mercy have yearnings for us and be pleased with us. Blessed be Thou, O Lord, who sanctifiest the Sabbath.". iii. 29b; Shab. 13, xliii. 13; II Sam. The Shemoneh Esrei - The Seventh Blessing - Part 2 As I understand the origin of these SHEMONEH ESREI - AMIDAH prayers (originally 18 prayers with one, the 12th, added between the destruction of the first and second Hebrew temple). "In loving-kindness and mercy," Hos. The Sephardim shorten the last benediction in the evening and morning services of the Ninth of Ab to this brief phrasing: "Thou who makest peace, bless Thy people Israel with much strength and peace, for Thou art the Lord of peace. 6, Midr. . Blessed be Thou, O Lord, who hearest prayer.". 191-193; Herzfeld, Gesch. a special supplication is recited, beginning with "Answer us, O Lord, answer us"; and in No. xvi. It is very short, though the variants are numerous (see below). Shemoneh Esrei: The Three Steps - The Jewish Press (Then follows the "Reeh" [see above], with such variations from the Sabbath formula as: "in gladness and joy" for "in love and favor"; "rejoice" for "rest"; and "Israel and Thy" or "the holy seasons" for "the Sabbath."). ), which psalm, nevertheless, seems to indicate the number of benedictions as nineteen (see Elbogen, l.c. 1. On fast-days, after No. x. to Jacob's reunion with his family in Egypt; No. 15; Isa. The Shemoneh EsreiThe Amidah is also called Shemoneh Esrei, which means "eighteen" (8+10), since originally there were eighteen blessings of the Amidah divided into three general types: Notice that this lists adds up to nineteen, not eighteen. Product Description. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. No. xiv. viii. Auerbach, p. 20), and Midr. is presented as in the Sephardic form (see above), but with the addition: "And may our prayers be sweet before Thee like the burnt offering and like the sacrifice. Then the reader concludes with the "Reeh," the middle Sabbath eulogy. 16, 17) regarding appearance before God on those days. (1887) 26-32; Loeb, Les Dix-huit Bndictions, in R. E. J. xix. Jewish Liturgy - Judaism 101 (JewFAQ) ; then to this, Ps. 6; Ps. "Protokolle der Zweiten Rabbinerversammlung," pp. the prefixing of the definite article to the adjective gives the context a new significance, viz., not "Thy name is holy," but "Thy name is 'the Holy One.'" ii. The "pious and poor" of the Psalms were the ideal types which the Pharisees sought to imitate. The reason given for this is the fear lest by tarrying too long or alone in the synagogue on the eve of the Sabbath the worshiper may come to harm at the hands of evil spirits. Allerdings lassen der Chabad-Nusach und Nusach Edot Hamizrach die fett gedruckten Wrter weg.
- Patrick McGovern is the Scientific Director of the Biomolecular Archaeology Project for Cuisine, Fermented Beverages, and Health at the University of Pennsylvania Museum in Philadelphia, where he is also an Adjunct Professor of Anthropology. In the popular imagination, he is known as the "Indiana Jones of Ancient Ales, Wines, and Extreme Beverages." dirty pastor jokes
Caption: “Dr. Pat” in the Lower Egyptian Gallery of the Penn Museum, with the largest sphinx in the Western hemisphere to his side and columns of the 13th c. B.C. Merenptah palace behind him. Photo by Alison Dunlap.
Ancient Brews Rediscovered and Re-Created
The Foreign Relations of the “Hyksos”
shemoneh esrei text
You must be what mbti types are mha characters? to post a comment.